AutoToken vs TokenStamp and Other VTT Token Makers
If you’re deciding between TokenStamp 2, Token Tool, Roll20’s built-in tools, and AutoToken, this page gives a practical side-by-side comparison focused on pricing, privacy, export quality, and workflow.
- Local background removal (on-device, no upload required for local mode)
- Premium frame vault
- 1024px free exports, 2048px Pro exports
- Cloud storage for Pro users
- Mask painting + edge hardness controls
- Built-in upscaling
- No watermarks on core exports
- Modern editor workflow
Feature Comparison Table
Checkmarks indicate strong support, X marks indicate missing support, and minus marks indicate partial or plan-dependent support.
| Comparison Point | AutoToken Web app (free core + optional Pro) | TokenStamp 2 Web app (free) | Token Tool (RollAdvantage) Desktop app | Roll20 Built-in Tools Inside Roll20 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Price Free vs limits vs paid upgrades | Supported: Free core editor, optional Pro at $6/mo. | Supported: Free web-based token maker. | Supported: Free desktop utility. | Partial: Included with Roll20 account. Feature depth varies by workflow and plan. |
Background Removal Method Local on-device processing vs external/cloud flow | Supported: Local background removal on-device. Optional cloud/AI alternatives are also available. | Not supported: No dedicated local cutout pipeline. | Not supported: No built-in local AI background removal. | Not supported: Not focused on local background-removal workflow. |
Export Quality / Resolution | Supported: 1024px free, 2048px Pro. | Partial: Standard VTT-sized exports. | Partial: Standard token export workflow. | Partial: Optimized for Roll20 tabletop flow. |
Frame Vault | Supported: Large free + premium frame collections. | Partial: Basic border options. | Partial: Overlay/stamp workflow, smaller built-in catalog. | Not supported: No dedicated premium frame-vault workflow. |
Cloud Save / Vault | Partial: Cloud storage available for Pro users. | Not supported: No built-in cloud token vault. | Not supported: Desktop/local file workflow. | Partial: Cloud assets live inside Roll20 ecosystem. |
Desktop vs Web Install required? | Supported: Web app, no install required. | Supported: Web app, no install required. | Not supported: Desktop app install required. | Supported: Browser-based platform. |
Privacy / Local Processing | Supported: Core background removal can stay on your device. | Partial: Browser-based editing, local ML cutout not the focus. | Partial: Local desktop editing but no dedicated local AI cutout. | Not supported: Primarily account/cloud workflow. |
Mask Painting + Edge Hardness | Supported: Built-in mask painting and edge controls. | Partial: Basic masking/cropping flow. | Partial: Manual prep tools, less integrated cutout flow. | Not supported: Limited advanced cutout tuning. |
Upscaling | Partial: Built-in upscaling (Pro). | Not supported: No integrated upscaling workflow. | Not supported: No integrated upscaling workflow. | Not supported: No dedicated token upscaling workflow. |
Watermarks on Core Exports | Supported: No watermarks on core exports. | Partial: Depends on surrounding tool chain and workflow. | Partial: Depends on surrounding workflow. | Partial: Depends on account plan and asset pipeline. |
Product capabilities can change over time. Treat this as a practical workflow snapshot rather than a legal specification.
Try AutoToken on your next token
Start with the free editor, process cutouts locally, apply frames, and export clean tokens without watermarks.